The question of whether to carry your M&P Shield pistol with the safety on or off is a hotly debated topic among firearm enthusiasts. There's no single right answer, as the best approach depends on your individual training, experience, and carry style. This guide will explore the pros and cons of each approach, helping you make an informed decision about what's safest for you.
Understanding the M&P Shield's Manual Safety
The Smith & Wesson M&P Shield, depending on the model, may or may not feature a manual thumb safety. Some models are equipped with a manual safety, while others rely solely on the trigger safety. It is crucial to know your specific model and its safety features. Consult your owner's manual if you're unsure.
This guide focuses on models with a manual safety. If your Shield lacks a manual safety, the considerations below regarding "safety on" versus "safety off" are irrelevant; your reliance will be solely on the trigger safety mechanism.
Carrying the M&P Shield with the Safety ON
Pros:
- Added Layer of Security: The most significant advantage is the extra layer of protection against accidental discharge. If the gun is dropped or bumped, the safety acts as a physical barrier, preventing the trigger from being pulled.
- Improved Peace of Mind: For many new or less experienced carriers, having the safety engaged provides a greater sense of security and reduces anxiety.
Cons:
- Slower Draw Time: Engaging the safety adds a crucial step to your draw stroke, potentially slowing your response time in a self-defense situation. This extra step requires consistent practice to ensure fluidity and efficiency.
- Increased Risk of Fumbling: Under stress, there's an increased risk of fumbling with the safety, potentially leading to a delay or malfunction. This risk is mitigated by rigorous training.
- Potential for Failure: While rare, there's always a theoretical possibility of safety failure.
Carrying the M&P Shield with the Safety OFF
Pros:
- Faster Draw and Response: This is the primary advantage. Having the safety off eliminates an extra step in your draw, allowing for a quicker response to a threat.
- Increased Efficiency: It streamlines your self-defense process, which can be critical in a high-stress situation.
Cons:
- Higher Risk of Accidental Discharge: This is the significant drawback. Without the safety engaged, the gun is ready to fire if the trigger is pulled. Extreme caution and responsible gun handling are paramount.
- Increased Responsibility: Carrying with the safety off demands a heightened level of awareness, responsible gun handling, and consistent training to mitigate risks.
Making the Right Choice for You
The decision of whether to carry your M&P Shield with the safety on or off is deeply personal. There is no universally "correct" answer. It depends on factors such as:
- Your Training Level: Experienced shooters who have rigorously practiced drawing and engaging the safety may be comfortable carrying with the safety off. Less experienced shooters may find the safety on provides a necessary layer of security.
- Your Carry Method: Concealed carry methods can influence your decision. Certain methods may make it easier or more difficult to engage or disengage the safety.
- Your Risk Tolerance: Your comfort level with the risks associated with each method is paramount.
Conclusion: Training is Key
Regardless of your chosen method, comprehensive training is absolutely essential. Regular practice with your M&P Shield is critical to ensure proficiency and safety, regardless of whether you carry with the safety on or off. Seek professional training from qualified instructors to develop safe and effective carrying and drawing techniques. Remember, responsible gun ownership involves constant vigilance and commitment to safety.
