Choosing between the Glock 17L and the Glock 34 often comes down to individual preferences and intended use. Both are excellent pistols, but their subtle differences cater to distinct needs. This in-depth comparison will help you decide which Glock best fits your shooting style and requirements.
Understanding the Key Differences: Size and Barrel Length
The most significant difference between the Glock 17L and the Glock 34 lies in their overall dimensions, specifically barrel length. The Glock 17L boasts a longer barrel (6.0 inches) compared to the Glock 34 (5.3 inches), resulting in a noticeably longer slide and overall pistol length. This translates to several key performance variations:
Barrel Length and Ballistics
-
Increased Velocity (Glock 17L): The longer barrel of the 17L allows for more complete powder burn, leading to slightly higher muzzle velocity and, consequently, a flatter trajectory. This is particularly advantageous for longer-range shooting.
-
Improved Accuracy Potential (Glock 17L): The longer sight radius of the 17L contributes to improved accuracy, especially at longer distances. The extra sight radius allows for finer aiming adjustments.
Overall Size and Weight
-
Longer and Heavier (Glock 17L): The extended barrel adds to the 17L's overall length and weight, making it slightly less concealable and potentially more cumbersome for some users. The added weight can also impact recoil management, making it feel slightly more stable for some shooters.
-
More Compact (Glock 34): The Glock 34 maintains a balance between a longer barrel than the standard Glock 17 and manageable size. It’s preferred by many competitive shooters for its maneuverability and balanced feel.
Intended Use: Competition vs. Practical Applications
The choice between these two models hinges significantly on the intended application:
Glock 17L: A Precision Tool
The Glock 17L, with its longer barrel and sight radius, is often favored for target shooting and long-range accuracy. While not impossible to conceal, its size makes it less suitable for concealed carry scenarios. It excels in situations requiring precise shots at extended ranges.
Glock 34: The Versatile Competitor
The Glock 34's popularity stems from its balanced design. The longer barrel provides superior accuracy over the standard Glock 17, while its more compact size enhances maneuverability. This makes it highly desirable for competitive shooting, such as USPSA and IPSC, where speed and accuracy are paramount. Its balanced size also makes it a popular choice for law enforcement and duty use.
Ergonomics and Handling: A Subjective Matter
Both pistols retain Glock's renowned ergonomic design. However, the difference in size translates into subtle differences in handling:
-
Recoil Management: The increased weight of the 17L may make it feel slightly less snappy in recoil for some shooters.
-
Concealability: The Glock 34 is more easily concealed than the 17L.
-
Maneuverability: The Glock 34's more compact size offers enhanced maneuverability in close-quarters scenarios.
Conclusion: The Right Glock for You
Ultimately, the choice between the Glock 17L and the Glock 34 depends on your priorities. The Glock 17L excels in accuracy and long-range shooting, while the Glock 34 offers a balance of accuracy and maneuverability ideal for competition and versatile applications. Consider your intended use, preferred handling characteristics, and personal preferences to determine which Glock best fits your needs. Consider renting or trying both models at a shooting range before making your final decision.
